El Niño 2026: the agriculture and fertiliser thesis, and the trade that survives it

Everyone is suddenly long the El Niño trade. Link by link the broad commodity bull does not hold; what survives is a narrow, India-only equity play on fertiliser producers, driven by the subsidy and the Strait of Hormuz, not the rain.

A two-part note. Part one tests the popular El Niño thesis as a chain (weather to crop prices to farm income to fertiliser demand, plus a war-driven supply squeeze) and finds it weak. The event has not started yet (the Pacific is neutral, about 82 per cent likely by summer), the harvest effect is small and cuts both ways, a poor harvest lifts prices only when stocks are thin, and Indian farm prices are walled off by policy so the demand link partly runs in reverse. The one genuinely strong force, the 2026 fertiliser spike, is a Strait of Hormuz supply shock that is already reversing, not a weather story. Part two builds the trade that does survive: an India-only equity play on listed fertiliser producers, because a weak monsoon there lands in the subsidy bill and producer margins rather than in crop prices. Screened with our own fair value and quality work across seven names, the conclusion is a barbell (a high-quality anchor plus deep-value asymmetry) with a finite shelf life tied to the Kharif season.

Nirbhai Verma

Independent analyst · founder, SvarQ Research

Open PDF ↗Download

▸ Thesis at a glance

The view: The broad El Niño commodity bull is weak and largely priced in. The trade that survives is a narrow, India-only equity play on fertiliser producers, driven by the subsidy regime and a Strait of Hormuz supply shock rather than the monsoon.
The implication: A barbell of listed Indian fertiliser producers rather than a blanket long: a high-quality anchor (Coromandel) and a deep-value bet (Chambal), with Paradeep and RCF the higher-conviction satellites. A policy and supply trade with a finite shelf life, not a long-term hold.
What would change it: A severe monsoon failure below 85 per cent of normal where demand destruction outweighs the subsidy benefit; the Hormuz squeeze easing so import prices and the subsidy uplift unwind; or a lag in subsidy disbursal. Exit after the Kharif harvest.